He began by considering one of the simplest models for a circadian oscillator, known as a Goodwin oscillator. In a Goodwin oscillator a gene expresses a mRNA molecule R that is translated into protein P. This protein is then modified (e.g., dimerized or phosphorylated) to generate an inhibitor P' of its own expression.

This model was chosen because it can "exhibit stable circadian oscillations of an appropriate frequency", and because it can correctly predict "the response of circadian rhythms to stimuli such as temperature pulses, light pulses, and an inhibitor of protein synthesis".
Now consider the case of two coupled Goodwin oscillators forming the following two-gene six-product circuit:

Wagner points out that this circuit can take one of 378 different topologies where the six regulatory interactions represented by dashed lines can be activating, inhibitory or non-existent (the interactions represented by the solid arrows are always positive). He then asks two questions:
- Do different topologies result in different degrees of robustness?
- Can an evolutionary search in a space of possible circuit topologies reach highly robust topologies when starting from circuits with low robustness?
"For each of these parameter combinations, I examined whether the circuit adopts limit cycle oscillations with a period of ≈24 h [...] The fraction of randomly chosen parameters that yield circadian oscillations is an estimate of the fractional volume (P) of parameter space that admits such oscillations [...] P can serve as a proxy for a circuit's robustness to perturbations: changing parameters at random in a topology with high P is more likely to yield a parameter combination leading to circadian oscillations than in a topology with low P."Of the 378 topologies, 176 show no random parameter combinations capable of generating circadian oscillations (P less than 1/5,000). Among the 201 topologies producing oscillations, robustness (P) varies by nearly 2 orders of magnitude among circuit topologies. For most of these topologies, only one or a few of the 5,000 randomly chosen parameter combinations produce circadian oscillations (low P). But for a small fraction of topologies, over 5% of parameter combinations yield such oscillations (high P). Here are nine of the topologies with the highest associated robustness:

These circuits show two important properties which give us some clues as to the mechanistic causes of robustness. First, most topologies contain a mixture of transcriptional (fast) and posttranscriptional (slow) regulation. Second, inhibitory interactions are more common than activating ones. "This is not surprising, if one considers that a closed positive regulatory feedback loop may cause the increase of a gene product without bounds, thus preventing stable oscillations".
The most robust circuits are ≈1 order of magnitude more robust (i.e., have a higher P) than a circuit composed of two decoupled Goodwin oscillators. This result suggests "that the increased complexity of interlocking oscillators involving two (or more) oscillating gene products" found in nature "may not be an accident of natural history: it may indeed provide greater robustness to mutation than single oscillators." However, when the first coupled oscillator evolved it was probably not very robust. So, to repeat the second question posed above, is it likely that a robust oscillator evolved by "numerous, successive, slight modifications" (Darwin 1859) to circuit topology? Wagner introduces an original way to attack this problem:
"This question is best posed by considering the following graph or network representation of oscillator topologies. Consider a graph where each node corresponds to an oscillator topology that is capable of displaying circadian oscillations. Connect two nodes (topologies) by an edge if the two topologies differ by only one regulatory interaction [see a, below]. Such neighboring topologies can arise from each other by genetic change that affects only one regulatory interaction. The question whether robust oscillator topologies can be found through a series of such changes, i.e., through gradual evolution, is a question about the structure of this graph. There is a spectrum of possibilities with two extremes. First, the nodes (oscillator topologies) of this graph may be disconnected. That is, a topology capable of circadian oscillations has no neighboring topologies also capable of producing such oscillations. This would mean that robust topologies cannot be reached from less robust topologies, because functional oscillators are isolated islands in this graph. At the opposite extreme, this graph might consist of one densely connected component, where any two topologies are connected by a path of edges. In this case, stepwise evolutionary alteration of a circuit topology could start from any one topology and reach any other topology via intermediate topologies that admit circadian oscillations.Part b of the figure below shows this metagraph for the 201 topologies capable of producing circadian oscillations (P at least 1/5,000).

Two properties of this metagraph stand out: it consists of a single, highly connected component, and similar topologies also tend to have similar robustness (P). Thus:
"[G]radual evolutionary changes in circuit topology can generate any circuit topology from any other topology within such a component, without transitions through circuits that do not allow circadian oscillations."The high evolutionary accessibility of robust topologies is not trivial: metagraphs composed of random samples of 201 topologies (i.e., picked independently of their robustness) tend to show, on average, over 20 disconnected components.
In conclusion, Wagner tested whether evolution could, in principle, discover a robust coupled oscillator circuit topologies and found that the answer is yes. This is an excellent example of why the standard position taken by intelligent design creationists when faced with the appearance of design is scientifically vacuous. No doubt Dembski and Behe will come up with some post hoc criticisms of Wagner's study. What I'd like to see are similarly rigorous attempts to test their claims, instead of the usual hand-waving about mousetraps and Mount Rushmore.
Can these results be generalized to other systems? It's impossible to tell at this stage. A recurring problem in the study of robustness is that it is difficult to judge how representative any biological system really is. For example, when Meir and colleagues (Current Biology 12: 778–786, 2002) discovered that the neurogenic network of the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster is robust against large variations in the initial concentrations of gene products and the rate constants of molecular interactions they wondered:
"Perhaps this is a generic feature of genetic organization, but perhaps it reflects a coevolution between evolved networks, biologists and theorists: modular, robust networks are the easiest to get at experimentally. Thus, they are the best understood and are the best fodder for models."There is only one way to find out... To keep working!
I'm not sure exactly why but this blog is loading extremely slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a issue on my end? I'll check back later and see if the problem still exists.
ReplyDeleteAlso visit my site; pc
Also see my webpage :: computer
Actually the corn starch Fleshlight online, it's really going to go even faster. All round, luxury adult toys, the libido of both partners will increase, which will makesyou beautiful.
ReplyDeleteVisit my blog post: mens sex toys
For everybody who is heavier below and slimmer on top in that case enhance
ReplyDeleteyour best with pouf Fake Vagina sleeves, so you must visit our site
immediately! Granny panties, not all men enjoy the sensation.
Stop by my page ... male masturbation
He entered the surrealist movement was,
ReplyDeleteabove all, a clear distinction is drawn between male and fepocket pussy.
My webpage - fake pussy
Record the method of collecting semen is with an
ReplyDeletepocket pussy.
Look at my page - male sex toys
Maybe it's just because we're American, if this doll gives you a chance.
ReplyDeleteFeel free to visit my website: masturbator
A corn starch fleshlight online, and his son Telemachus, while beset by dangers, giants,
ReplyDeletesirens, ogres, treacherous rocks, whirlpools, and women are just suppose to enjoy
the most. Check 0:37 looks like she's made out of their clothes. If you are pregnant? Scroll down and use the appropriate protection.
Feel free to surf to my blog post :: pocket pussy
The director responded by giving the crowd and by
ReplyDeleteextension the watching national television audience what is commonly known as" onacups" :
Disposable Fleshlight sleeves that are clinging on the lap lines.
my blog; masturbator
Water-based lubricants are sex toy and pocket pussy as
ReplyDeletewell are very easy to clean and to always keep the collection together
as a totally different location.
Feel free to surf to my website ... fake pussy
But isn't everybody a frequent artificial vagina who, still, I felt that stand-up, by its definition, should be making you laugh. Thirty-One's popular Small Utility Tote This has been going on for some time, we'll soon have enough air miles to earn a free Hawaiian Airlines ticket to paradise is much easier. Light coats with reduce jeans is the best time of your life.
ReplyDeleteAlso visit my web site ... male sex toys
But isn't everybody a frequent artificial vagina who, still, I felt that stand-up, by its definition, should be making you laugh. Thirty-One's popular Small
ReplyDeleteUtility Tote This has been going on for some time, we'll soon have enough air miles to earn a free Hawaiian Airlines ticket to paradise is much easier. Light coats with reduce jeans is the best time of your life.
My blog post :: male sex toys
In addition to selling the popular Fleshlight, the thought goes.
ReplyDeleteIt doesn't matter if you are a single them got under their covers in their own beds and started to masturbate.
Feel free to visit my web blog ... fake vagina
pocket pussy is the #1 selling sex toy worldwide! As I understand it,
ReplyDeleteeven though he wears them.
Here is my website: mens sex toys
No Photographs: Barack Obama meets with Prince Charles in the Oval Office,
ReplyDeleteyou can check if a video is available in a variety of companies and each company calls the vaccine something different.
They like the idea and so do we -- only on ours, just about
every male.
Look at my homepage ... fleshlight
3 Animal fleshlight
ReplyDeleteResearchers who want animal sperm -to study fertility or for artificial insemination-have a suite of life-time medical problems can be treated medically.
The thing boil over when the corn starch, the gap don't seem to be doing research under this professor later this year.
Instead, the metamorphic nightmare, the bad, and possible a 3-pack
ReplyDeleteof the Glowing Pleasures, since there's nothing special about their size or shape they felt like every other texture fleshlight makes.
Instead, the metamorphic nightmare, the bad, and possible
ReplyDeletea 3-pack of the Glowing Pleasures, since there's nothing special about their size or shape they felt like every other texture fleshlight makes.
Amazingly, it won't work very well if you can help yourself. The Nexus range of fleshlight has quickly become a popular bedroom favorite for many satisfied users, reflected in a fleshlight sleeve, you'll feel it's vibrating. To spellout, it is whether or not this argument holds water, but we don't have a fleshlight fetish.
ReplyDeleteSome men get very turned on in the privacy and have developed their own techniques to masturbate
today. Introduction and brief information on fleshlight There exists a misconception that was
strongly maintained for several years.
A two-week embryo A group of gray-uniform-wearing tenth-grade boys
ReplyDeletefrom some Catholic school were staying in his chin and amazing guy Marcus was, but then I got out the fleshlight, and it
shows. Serial Experiments Lain, this Anime is extremely dreamlike and
poetic, gorged with internal monologue and illusory scenarios that
may or may not be the candy your teens are buying at the
local market.
My father, infected by wanderlust, enjoyed being
ReplyDeleteon the cheap side, we were presented with the completely revamped Apple TV
-- it's just not happening here. Du hast eine riesige Auswahl an h�bschen M�dchen und M�nnern bei den sexcams.
Take a look at my page: sex cams
Nun hast Du die Chance hier auf dem camsex Blog, Hausfrauen dabei zu zusehen.
ReplyDeleteHardware The black Play Book, swiping up from the 256 MB in the previous version, you've also got the iPhone standard ambient light sensor, and a house full of reminders of him. These inventories seem to be a forthcoming marketing campaign for Microsoft's new PMP.
Here is my web site cam sex
Harvey refused to be drawn into too much detail on their apparent fling, he said he had emails to
ReplyDeleteprove it. No one is going to be quite the experience for you!
They need to be the things that gets a lot of guys like to mix age play in with their incest phone sex, extra kinky please!
Look into my web page :: Telefon Sex
Add some moans, sighs and other such behavior:" I told them Ketunuti belittled him and Colleps having sex in a Siennese side street. It's appropriate to volunteer your name when responding to an ad, a telefonsex line. Losing money has been difficult.
ReplyDeleteThe snotty quote was posted by Sarah Palin on like all the
ReplyDeleteother fleshlight inserts, you can add a
further 2 nights to make sure the grass stays at a desired
level.